• cellulaire montrant le logo de la revue

    Volume 81-2 is online!

    The latest issue (81-2) is now available in open access. RI/IR is marking its 80th anniversary with a publication that deserves special recognition. In this issue, we are publishing a summary article covering each decade that outlines the journal’s contributions to our understanding of labor and employment. 

     

  • ordinateur montrant google - crédit firmbee . com - unsplash

    Google Top 18

    Relations Industrielles/Industrial Relations is now #18 on Google Scholar’s top 100 french journals list! 

  • Campus Hiver

2015-2025: A Decade of Work and Employment Metamorphosis

2015-2025: A Decade of Work and Employment Metamorphosis

RIIR_2015-2025

By Anthony M. Gould, professor at Département des relations industrielles, Université Laval and former editor of RI/IR

Content published in Relations industrielles/Industrial Relations from 2015 to 2025 (covering editions 70 to 80) represents unambiguously the carrying forward of a decades-long emphasis on a pluralist, indeed an often decidedly critical, perspective of the employment relationship and, more generally, deployment of an industrial sociology lens to expose areas of employee risk and vulnerability. As the period unfolded, this emphasis broadened to progressively and unprecedentedly account for institutional circumstances and experiences from outside of Quebec and Canada as well as wider scope of what counts as legitimate analytic fodder – to include more insight from, for example, the arena of occupational health and safety. Also, as the decade progressed, there was a conspicuous uptick in essentially theoretical, sometimes polemic (essay style) contributions, those making a generic – jurisdiction-independent – case. As implied, during the decade the journal never lost its essentially industrial relations and probing identity, in crucial respects doubling down on this character. Although it always accommodated human resource management contributions, none of its three editors in the reference period ever permitted distinctively employer-orientated content to rise above approximately 40 percent of total content, with most of these latter kinds of contributions appearing in the first few years of the decade. For example, in 2015, about 13 were unambiguously HR-related, in 2020 (the COVID year) the number was – at most – three or four, and, in 2024, it was approximately six (this micro-analysis does not include the year 2025 which included two special issues which were patently not about human resource management-related topics).

The year 2015 commenced with a set of compelling articles addressing an approximately equivalent mix of orthodox IR (for example, collective bargaining in Quebec and generic notions of employee well being) and HRM papers (for example, on employee turnover, absenteeism mitigation and work-team trust development). Also, in 2015 (edition 2) there was a special issue on union renewal within Europe. With respect to theory-orientated contributions, editions 3 and 4 (70) in 2015, notably showcased well-cited articles authored by, for example, Kaufman and Gall as well as a special issue on varieties of capitalism wherein Hall and Soskice’s original conception was road-tested and critiqued in jurisdictions from North America and Europe.

In 2016, the 2015-25 decade`s first series of articles about workplace and health and safety are profiled. This emphasis is conspicuous particularly in editions one and three of 2016.  Also, in 2016 – and in each of the four editions – there are notably contributions that have a decidedly HRM feel – including one on comparative HRM. The same year, 2016, (particularly edition two) – represents the high-water mark for HRM content, a trend which attenuates in editions three and four, for the most part, about work sociology (see, for example, Burchielli`s and Delaney`s contribution dealing with Argentina) and work-related psychology (addressing, for example, the psychological contract). 

The year 2017 saw the publication of two special issues, one concerning evolving workplace health and safety challenges in Europe (edition one) and the other addressing new frontiers in the employment relationship (edition three). These special issues mostly dealt with Canadian matters but, notably, did attract several papers from Asia, Europe and the United States. The following year (2018) kicked off with another special issue addressing HRM renewal in the 21st century, showcasing a series of generic, philosophically orientated contributions. Indeed, the topics dealt with in this special issue diverge somewhat from those typically addressed in, say, exclusively human resource management publications – in key respects not having a garden-variety HRM look and feel. The rest of the 2018 calendar year saw the pages of Relations industrielles/Industrial Relations return to a its standard long-term focus, with the bulk of content being about topics such as union renewal, collective bargaining and the impact of legislation in (mostly) Quebec and Canadian contexts. 

In 2019, Relations industrielles/Industrial Relations broke somewhat with its established tradition in publishing articles on avant-gardist topics of emerging consequence, particularly insofar as Canada is concerned. For example, in that year it showcased a – now – well downloaded piece by Helen Lam on the work and employment-related implications of marijuana legalisation. Another such iconoclastic contribution of the same year was from Clotilde Coron which presents an ontology of manager – as opposed to, say, operative – workloads. These kinds of papers roughly delineated the beginning of a widening emphasis in the years 2019 and 2020 (COVID year), exemplified in scholarship addressing, for example, health and safety in China (Xue, Tang and Walter, 2019), a polemic piece from France concerning manager workloads (Coron, 2019), abusive supervision in China (Seo and Chung, 2019) and employer collective action in the UK (Demougin, Gooberman and Hauptmeier, 2019).

In 2021, as the world haltingly reemerged from the pandemic-induced lockdown, several work-related contextual elements were permanently changed in such a way as to have long-term implications for employment relations scholarly and research agendas. Two of these, in particular, showed up conspicuously in the manuscripts submitted to Relations industrielles/Industrial Relations. Specifically, the years 2022, 2023 and 2024 present contributions about, on the one hand, remote work and employment forms (at least 14 peer-reviewed articles) and, on the other, integration of hyper-new technology into work processes (at least eight peer-reviewed articles). These papers do not take account of the special issues in 2023 (78, editions 3 and 4) addressing what – just prior to the mid-decade – were the hot topics of platform employment forms and the future of work wherein, in light of artificial intelligence, there was widespread speculation that work did not have a future. As such, it is fair to conclude that, in the years following the pandemic – years which saw the emergence of Chat-GPT and its subsequent derivatives – the journal was particularly responsive to a rapidly altering global context. These years (2022, 2023, 2024 and 2025) also saw, for the first time in the journal`s history, contributions from Marocco, Turkey, Israel and jurisdictions in the Arabian Gulf, papers which will have historical import inasmuch as they emanate from parts of the world wherein new geopolitical tensions and armed conflict were challenging – in some case reforging – national boundaries and cultures. 

 

References

Berchielli, R and Delaney, A. The Invisibilization and Denial of Work in Argentinian Garment Homework. Relations industrielles/Industrial Relations, 71(3).

Demougin, P., Gooberman, L. and Hauptmeier, M. (2019). The Unexpected Survival of Employer Collective Action in the United Kingdom. Relations industrielles/Industrial Relations, 74(2).

Kaufman, B. and Gall, G. (2015). Advancing Industrial Relations Theory: An Analytical Synthesis of British-American and Pluralist-Radical Ideas. Relations industrielles/Industrial Relations, 70 (3).

Lam. H. (2019). Marijuana Legalization in Canada: Insights for Workplaces from Case Law Analysis. Relations industrielles/Industrial Relations, 74(1).

Seo, Y and Chung, S. W. (2019). Abusive Supervision, Psychological Capital, and Turnover Intention: Evidence from Factory Workers in China. Relations industrielles/Industrial Relations, 74 (2).

Xue, C., Tang, L., and Walter, D. (2019) Occupational Health and Safety Indicators and Under-Reporting: Case Studies in Chinese Shipping. Relations industrielles/Industrial Relations, 74(1).